Let’s Make a Deal
Agencies for sale or wanted
Hover your mouse over a state to see if there are Agencies listed for Sale.
Agency For Sale
Florida
Fort Walton Beach
Michael R Cheney Insurance Inc
850.974.4829
Email: michaelcheney62@gmail.com
Asking Price: $1,350,000
PIF: 2500 Premium: $6,900,000
Number of Staff: 3
Number of Licensed Staff: 3
Agency for sale in Fort Walton Beach, FL, as agent is looking to retire.
Date Posted: April 16, 2025
Georgia
N Metro Atlanta
SAMM Business Marketing
678-223-7397
Email: nicole@sammconsulting.com
Asking Price: $665,000
Premium: $3,400,000
Number of Staff: 2
$3.4M book in N Metro Atlanta. Great loss ratio & retention. Long established agency. Call today for more info.
Date Posted: December 11, 2025
Missouri
St Louis
Scott Foelsch Agency Inc
314.800.7498
Email: sfoelsch@yahoo.com
PIF: 1500 Asking Price: $485,000
Premium: $4,450,000
Number of Staff: 1
Number of Licensed Staff: 2
Date Posted: May 13, 2025
North Carolina
Western, NC
SAMM Business Marketing
678-223-7397
Email: nicole@sammconsulting.com
Asking Price: $950,000
Premium: $4,500,000
Number of Staff: 2
$4.5M Book in Western, NC Great loss ratio & retention. Call today for more info.
Dated Posted: November 26, 2025
Ohio
Columbus
Loretta Powell Agency
614.306.8823
Email: lorettapowell2@allstate.com
PIF: 3400 | Asking Price: $780,000
Premium: $3,800,000
Number of Staff: 1
Number of Licensed Staff: 1
Looking to sell.
Date Posted: November 12, 2025
Pennsylvania
Lebanon
Tim McShane Agency Inc.
717.269.0132
Email: tmcshane@allstate.com
Asking Price: $880,000
PIF: 2593 | Premium: $4,400,000
Number of Staff: 2
Number of Licensed Staff: 2
43 year agency relationship with Allstate. Excellent retention with cross sell opportunities, referrals and ALR potential. LSPs are bi-lingual and have 15 years combined experience.
Date Posted: October 27, 2025
Updated: March 12, 2026
Whitehall
Gary Chitwood
720.902.5200
Email: gchitwood@g-forceac.com
Annual Premium: $2,265,000
Annual Revenue: $252,000
Asking Price: $525,000
Retention: 92.11
Number of Licensed Staff: 1
Premium Agency in Highly Sought-After Pennsylvania Suburb!
This established $2,650,000 premium agency is located in a highly sought-after Pennsylvania suburb, ideally located near the Poconos & the Allentown metro area. The agency owner has built an amazing business and is looking for the right successor to take over the reins and continue growing. The agency has been a multiple trip- and bonus-winning location. The Whitehall area is an easy place to own a business, has an inviting community feel, highly rated public schools, & easy access to all the amenities of a larger city. The Whitehall area has a median home price of $335,000 and an average income of approximately $82,000. Families represent 65% of the community, and nearly 55% of residents own their homes. Search no more, you have found that turnkey opportunity that helps balance work and family!
Date Posted: December 5, 2025